Buck Bond Group

2017 Planning for ERISA Multiemployer Defined Benefit Plan Operations

by , and Tags: ,

Volume 39 | Issue 139

Download this FYI In-Depth as a printable PDF

The calendar provided in this FYI In-Depth will help you set up your own schedule of activities to address as the year progresses so that you do not miss important deadlines for your qualified plans. As you evaluate the various tasks, you can confirm suitable deadlines with your vendors for their completion. Our Reporting and Disclosure Guide will also help you identify and address other event-based and participant-specific activities. As you make your plans, we discuss a number of key issues for you to consider (along with the calendar deadlines) in 2017.

Review of Plan Administration

In addition to verifying that routine tasks are monitored in accordance with plan terms and administrative policies — such as making required minimum distributions, sending suspension of benefits notices, and attending to the myriad annual reporting and disclosure requirements — administrators must be on the alert to some not-so-common tasks. Here are some key areas to watch:

Brush Up on the Multiemployer Pension Reform Act of 2014. The Multiemployer Pension Reform Act of 2014, signed into law in late December 2014, contains many funding and PBGC-related changes that created concern among stakeholders in multiemployer plans. The ability of trustees and administrators to detect issues and know when to consult with trusted advisors is critical in efforts to assure compliance. Plan trustees and administrators should review the rules and communicate again with their participant and contributing employer population about the meaning and applicability of the MPRA’s provisions. For plans in the “critical and declining status” zone that expect to exercise their ability to suspend accrued benefits, suitable communications should happen early next year. Our For Your Information from January 12, 2015, provides an overview of this law.

Articles on regulatory guidance issued since the law was enacted include:

Comment:  Despite efforts by a number of plans to utilize the new benefit suspension option, to date, Treasury has rejected all such applications.

Review and analyze insurance coverage. Two basic types of insurance are available to protect the plan:

Fidelity bond. A fidelity bond is required for every fiduciary of an employee benefit plan and every person who handles funds or other property of such a plan, with a few exceptions. On an annual basis, plans that require a fidelity bond should review existing bonds to ensure they have at least the required minimum coverage and that the elected level is appropriate for the plan. (In most circumstances, the amount of the required bond is capped at $500,000 for a plan without an employer securities fund and $1,000,000 for plans that hold employer securities.)

Fiduciary liability insurance. Insurance can be purchased to protect fiduciaries and the plan against liability or losses occurring due to a plan fiduciary’s act or omission. Fiduciaries are personally liable for losses incurred by a plan due to their breach; insurance can cover some or all of these losses. Recently, obtaining fiduciary liability insurance in the appropriate amount has become more imperative. DOL has stepped up reviews and is keeping score of ever-increasing monetary recoveries resulting from their investigations. This is in addition to dramatic settlements arising from ERISA class action litigation.

It’s important to analyze the insurance policy’s major defined terms to understand exactly what risks it covers. Furthermore, understanding when these policies are triggered is crucial to knowing whether the plan and its fiduciaries are adequately protected. An annual review of these policies may illuminate the requirement to report certain events to the insurer within a specific time frame to collect on a claim.

Key Point: Many policies cover compliance fees and penalties, such as those imposed by the IRS under their Voluntary Correction Program, but require timely notification to the insurer.

Get set to trigger automatic payments. Plans can call for the automatic distribution of former employee benefits with values up to the $5,000 cashout limit without the participant’s affirmative consent. For values between $1,000 and $5,000, absent directions from the participant about how to make the payment, a default IRA rollover is generally required. Some plan sponsors had reduced the plan cashout limit to $1,000 to avoid the obligation of selecting a suitable vendor for the IRA. Some are reconsidering this decision in light of ever-increasing PBGC premiums and the larger number of established IRA providers that now offer such services. Amend your plan as appropriate if a change is warranted, and assure administration is in keeping with the plan document.

In addition to the automatic cashout of small payments, another situation may require payments without specific elections by plan participants. Many defined benefit plans specify that vested participants who have terminated employment are required to commence benefit distributions upon attainment of the plan’s normal retirement age. In this case, plan administrators need to provide suitable qualified joint and survivor (QJSA) notices prior to that date, and then put the benefit in pay status as the plan requires. In the absence of a waiver of the QJSA, a plan in this situation automatically begins distributions in the QJSA form.

Remind participants of any opportunity to name beneficiaries. Many plan administrators have had to sort out competing claims for death benefits because of unclear or missing beneficiary designations. These disputes can sometimes result in costly litigation. Most plans must make a participant’s spouse the default beneficiary. If the plan offers a choice, and a participant wants survivor benefits paid to someone else, such as children, parents, or a favorite charity, a properly executed beneficiary designation is the ticket. Make a point of reminding plan participants to consider updating their beneficiary designations.

Identify lost participants with vested benefits. Returned plan notices, statements, or distribution checks should trigger timely research to find lost participants. The sooner searches are started, the more likely it will be that terminated participants whose addresses have changed can be located. Although default rollover IRAs can be set up for participants with benefit values up to the cashout limit, other missing participants must be addressed at some point, and DOL is now auditing the extent to which plan sponsors fulfill this obligation (see our March 15, 2016 For Your Information). At plan termination, PBGC will accept funds to cover missing participants but will require the administrator to make a diligent effort, including the use of a locator service, to find former workers due a pension. Proposed changes to the program (see our October 5, 2016 For Your Information) would modify the search requirements to match DOL guidance for DC plans, including a requirement to search other employer plan records.

Based on the latest update to the Form 5500 instructions, the plan must take reasonable steps to locate participants/beneficiaries to avoid reporting a failure to provide a benefit when due.

Address foreign asset reporting obligations. In an effort to address tax evasion, money laundering and terrorist financing concerns, compliance requirements mandate reporting of assets held by foreign financial institutions (including retirement plans) and benefit distributions to certain individuals. Plan fiduciaries will want to assess compliance with these requirements, particularly the Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA), the Report of Foreign Bank and Financial Accounts (FBAR), and regulations issued by Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC). Our June 12, 2014 For Your Information outlines these requirements.

Plan Amendments, Filings and Documentation

Do your plan documents correctly describe the plan provisions as intended, and are summary plan descriptions and administrative procedures in sync with the official documents?

Service Providers Need to Know

Have you provided your actuary, consultant, TPA, etc. with copies of current signed documents? Your service providers need up-to-date information about you and your plans to be able to spot issues and assure quality service. Make sure to keep them in the loop!

Evaluate the need for plan amendments – and deadlines. IRS procedures call for executing amendments by the end of the plan year in the case of discretionary amendments, and provide extended amendment periods for modifications necessary to address changes in legal requirements. If you implemented discretionary changes during the year, make sure documentation is inked before the plan year is over.

If you missed making required amendments, consider IRS’ correction program. Until January 1, 2017, the applicable fee for a Voluntary Correction Program (VCP) submission that addresses only a failure to amend a plan in a timely manner is reduced by 50 percent if it is made within one year after the expiration of the amendment deadline. Starting in 2017, IRS will announce the VCP fees and associated rules in its annual Revenue Procedure for written determinations issued each January. We expect that IRS will continue to offer discounted VCP fees when sponsors voluntarily correct plan document failures within a short time after the deadline (such as one year) and prior to audit. Our October 21, 2016 For Your Information provides an update on the most recent changes.

Make sure your summary plan description matches your plan document. In addition to being a disclosure required under ERISA, the SPD plays an important role in ERISA disputes, and a well-drafted and well-integrated plan and SPD will minimize successful challenges to plan determinations or fiduciary decisions. Make sure it, or a timely summary of material modifications (SMM), reflects any plan amendments made during the plan year. Don’t forget that an SPD must generally be restated and redistributed every five years.

Key Point. A factor in many plan challenges is the statute of limitations for taking an official complaint to the federal courts for review. Sponsors should confirm that plan documents state a statute of limitations period and announce that period in summary plan descriptions as well as benefit claim denial communications.

Create or update your investment policy statement. For plan investments, fiduciaries must ascertain whether the plan has an investment policy statement (IPS) and guidelines and, if not, fiduciaries should consider adopting one. If an IPS is in place, it should be reviewed in light of current economic conditions. The DOL has encouraged plan fiduciaries to adopt written statements of investment policy and stated that compliance with ERISA’s prudence requirement calls for maintaining proper documentation of the activities of the investment manager and of the named fiduciaries of the plan in monitoring the investment manager.

Assemble and maintain documentation. Keeping plans up to date is crucial — but don’t toss the old documents. Plan participants and beneficiaries may request prior plan materials and plan administrators need to address requests within a 30-day window. Failure to comply can lead to legal challenges; a court may hold a plan administrator who fails to comply personally liable for up to $110 per day per affected person from the date of failure. Along with plan documents, SPDs, and SMMs, be sure to create and maintain records of participant data, such as proof of benefit distributions, benefit elections, and beneficiary designations. Arrange for continued access to documents even after termination of the plan.

Actuarial and Financial Disclosure

Multiemployer pension plans face a number of disclosure requirements aimed at ensuring that participants, beneficiaries, employee representatives, and contributing employers have sufficient information to properly monitor the plan’s funding and financial status. Within 30 days of a request from one of these parties, the plan administrator is required to provide:

  • Periodic actuarial reports (including any sensitivity testing)
  • Quarterly, semi-annual or annual financial reports
  • Applications filed with the secretary of the Treasury for an extension of funding amortization periods

In addition, a plan sponsor or administrator must provide estimated employer withdrawal liability information within 180 days of a written request by a contributing employer.

Ensuring that reports are completed and available for delivery upon request and developing a protocol for addressing withdrawal liability requests will help avert DOL penalties of up to $1,632/day for failing to furnish them.

Communicating with Your Actuary

2017 presents an opportunity for continuing discussion on rational funding expectations, managing escalating PBGC premiums, and reviewing reasonability of valuation assumptions.

Consider mortality and other assumptions. Most likely, your plan population is living longer and the cost of defined benefits will generally increase over time. At some point, these mortality improvements should be reflected in your mortality assumption to ensure that costs are reasonably estimated and users of your actuarial information are informed. Trustees may wish to consider the use of fully generational tables or embrace alternatives to the Society of Actuaries’ RP-2014 base mortality table. Recent adjustments to improvement scales used with the table should be considered and are reviewed in our October 8, 2015 FYI Alert. Consider having an experience study performed to facilitate adjusting mortality assumptions to better reflect the plan’s covered population.

Trustees and their actuaries will also want to consider changes in other assumptions that may coincide with mortality improvements. In response to longer life expectancy and the longer period of time for making retirement savings last, many employees are planning to continue working beyond the plan’s “normal” retirement date. Aligning plan retirement assumptions with this new paradigm can reduce plan liabilities, particularly for retiree medical plans and pension plans with suspension of benefits provisions and generous early retirement subsidies. On the other hand, it can also increase liabilities for a plan that provides generous actuarial increases to those electing late retirement.

Address escalating PBGC premiums. PBGC premium rates for multiemployer defined benefit plans have increased significantly over the past few years. Since 2014, the premium rate has increased from $12 to $28 (for 2017) per plan participant, and will continue to be indexed after 2017. Increasing PBGC premiums continue to put more pressure on funds to achieve higher returns or require higher contributions from employers to maintain their funded status. A data cleanup resulting in lower participant counts will help lower premiums. Review forecasts of future premiums and determine what tactics make sense to manage this expense.

Meeting Your Fiduciary Duties Selecting and Monitoring Investments

Most multiemployer plans use alternative investments, and there is a possibility of increased government attention in this area. So-called “alternatives” have many appealing qualities for pension plans, but there are downsides as well. The lack of liquidity should not become an issue when the associated pension payments are far in the future — but liquidity is needed when the monies eventually come due. The lack of liquidity can also lead to a lack of transparency (the underlying investments are not necessarily disclosed frequently) and difficulties in pricing (since they are not traded frequently on the open market to establish a fair value). Some alternatives, like hedge funds, are subject to less scrutiny from regulators, and those pose additional risks in terms of governance. Accordingly, fiduciaries of a pension plan (the board of trustees) should understand all the investments in the plan’s portfolio. Alternatives are significantly more complex than traditional investments and, if not fully understood, they can do more harm than good to a plan’s portfolio. Trustees should be clear about their objectives in identifying alternatives that fit their needs. Simply pouring funds into alternatives without a strategy can result in bad outcomes.

DOL guidance from 2015 on “social” investments reinstated the so-called “all things being equal” test, under which fiduciaries can consider socially responsible investment goals as a tie-breaker in choosing among investment alternatives that otherwise feature equal risk and return. Fiduciaries interested in pursuing socially responsible investments can rely on this guidance — but still cannot accept lower returns or take on greater risk. Plan administrators and trustees should have a process for periodically reviewing all plan investment options. Our November 12, 2015 For Your Information discusses the DOL guidance.

In Closing

Planning with trusted advisors to identify tasks and set compliance goals is an important first step for assuring smooth operations in 2017. In addition to the key items noted above, trustees may want to perform an annual “checkup” (i.e., a review of operational practices and fiduciary responsibilities) to address plan expenses, design considerations, and investments and confirm compliance with the terms of the plan document and investment policy statement, if any. Trustees may elect to conduct their own self-audit or contract with an independent party. Regardless of who performs the audit, identifying problems and initiating corrections in advance of any official agency audit is the preferred course of action.

Calendar of Significant Multiemployer Defined Benefit Plan Compliance Tasks[1]

Action Item

Due Date


2015 Form 5500 basic information and Schedule MB posting (assumes October 17, 2016 filing) January 15, 2017
Form 1099-R to participants (or write letter for 30-day extension) January 31, 2017
Form 945 to IRS (to report income withheld on distributions) January 31, 2017


Form 945 (alternative date, if withholding deposits timely made) February 10, 2017
Form 1099-R to IRS (if paper; or file Form 8809 for 30-day extension) February 28, 2017


Notice of intent to request prior year amortization extension March 1, 2017
Request for prior year minimum funding amortization extension March 15, 2017
Report US source income of foreign persons: Form 1042-S to participants and IRS (or file Form 8809 for 30-day extension for 1042-S filing with IRS; write letter to request 30-day extension for providing 1042-S to participants; Form 1042 to IRS (or file Form 7004 for 6-month extension ) March 15, 2017
Zone certification for 2017 year from enrolled actuary to IRS and trustees March 31, 2017
Form 1099-R to IRS (if electronic; or file Form 8809 for 30-day extension) March 31, 2017


Required minimum distributions for first time qualifying participants April 1, 2017
Form 990-T return of unrelated business income for prior year (or Form 8868 to request filing extension). This tax is sometimes triggered if the plan earns income from certain plan investments (for example, limited partnership interests) April 18, 2017
Notice of Endangered or Critical Status/Notice of Election to be in Critical Status/Notice of Projection to be in Critical Status in a Future Plan Year (assuming actuarial certification signed on March 31) [2] April 30, 2017
Annual Funding Notice April 30, 2017


Summary of material modifications if amendments adopted in 2016 July 29, 2017
Form 5330 excise tax on funding deficiency, nondeductible contribution, prohibited transaction, etc. (or file Form 5558 to request 6-month extension) July 31, 2017
2016 Forms 5500 and 8955-SSA (or Form 5558 to request an extension) July 31, 2017
Statement of deferred vested benefits (SSA information) to participants (unless on Form 8955-SSA extension) July 31, 2017


Summary plan report to employee organizations and contributing employers, if not on Form 5500 extension August 30, 2017


Minimum funding contribution (balance due for 2016 year) September 15, 2017


2016 Forms 5500, 8955-SSA, and SSA information (to participants), if on Form 5558 extension October 16, 2017
PBGC premium due October 16, 2017


Notice of insolvency benefit level, if applicable for 2018 (if insolvency determination by September 3, 2017) [3] November 2, 2017
Summary plan report to employee organizations and contributing employers, if on Form 5558 extension November 15, 2017
Funding improvement plan or rehabilitation plan adoption November 26, 2017


Notice of funding waiver request for 2016 December 17, 2017
Notice of funding improvement plan or rehabilitation schedule December 26, 2017
Minimum funding waiver request for 2016 December 31, 2017
Required minimum distributions December 31, 2017
Triennial benefit statements/ annual alternative notice December 31, 2017
Last day to adopt discretionary plan amendments for 2017 December 31, 2017
Request change in funding method December 31, 2017
Request for approval of retroactive amendment reducing accrued benefits (to 2015 plan year) December 31, 2017

[1] Assumes calendar plan year. Does not account for short plan years, or new plans. Weekend rule generally applies to filing deadlines and certain other acts under tax rules, but not contributions and other Title I ERISA obligations.

[2] Due 30 days after the date the actuary signs the certification. March 31 is the last permissible date for the actuary to do so.

[3] Required to be filed electronically. See our September 28, 2015 For Your Information.