Buck Bond Group

DC pensions schemes are missing the point, Buck research finds

New research reveals the concerns many businesses have about their aging workforce.

LONDON, April 9, 2019 – Buck, a leading consulting, administration, and technology services firm specialising in pensions and employee benefits, has today launched new research results which underline the need for employers to review what they expect their Defined Contribution (DC) pensions scheme to achieve for their business and their employees, specifically as it relates to talent management strategies. Without further support, businesses are likely to face a disengaged workforce as staff remain reluctantly employed past retirement age.

The findings, revealed in the paper ‘DC Pensions – What is the point?’, show that more than two fifths of employers (44%) are concerned about the long-term impact on the business if employees cannot afford to stop working. Despite this, most pensions schemes do not have sufficient contributions to deliver good retirement outcomes for staff, meaning there is a disconnect between what employers want from their DC pension schemes and what is actually likely to happen.

With recent research in Fidelity’s retirement saving guidelines revealing that employees need to save an average of 13% of their annual household income between the ages of 25 and 68 to maintain a similar standard of living in retirement, average DC contributions are simply not enough to provide this level of savings for employees.

The study also showed that a quarter of employers (25%) are concerned about the reputational risk that could arise should employees fail to have an adequate income in retirement. The risks associated with an ageing workforce have become greater following the removal of default retirement in 2011. Whilst there are many positives to having an age-diverse workforce, businesses risk limiting company and employee growth when employees remain part of the business because they have to rather than because they want to.

The research also found that a growing minority (38%) of employers are becoming increasingly interested in supplementary saving vehicles – such as ISAs – to help employees with wider savings goals alongside retirement planning. This suggests that companies are moving towards a more holistic approach in supporting their employees’ financial wellbeing, although it is too early to determine whether this has a beneficial knock on effect on retirement planning

The survey asked 50 employers a series of questions on a wide range of pension-related topics to help businesses understand what employers actually want from their pension. The employers covered different sizes and sectors and have over 500,000 UK employees between them.

Mark Pemberthy, Head of DC and Wealth at Buck in the UK comments:
“DC contribution rates aren’t doing enough to help staff manage their post-work life. Although auto-enrolment has been a broadly positive action, it’s caused most employees to switch off from their savings, thinking that their monthly contributions will be enough to sustain them. However, it’s not enough for a comfortable retirement. That’s not to say that employees need to shoulder the burden themselves. Businesses need to dedicate themselves to providing more education around pensions, investing in their staff’s future and empowering employees to confidently plan for their retirement.”

About Buck

Buck is an integrated HR and benefits consulting, administration, and technology services provider. Headquartered in New York City, with global operations, Buck is focused on helping its clients realize the best organizational performance for their business while driving positive health, wealth, and career outcomes for their people. For additional information, visit www.buck.com.

Media contact:

Taneesha Pawar / Max Daniels
+44 (0)20 7440 8670